Justice Obiora Egwuatu of the Federal High Court in Abuja has stepped down from presiding over the case filed by Kogi Central Senator Natasha Akpoti-Uduaghan against Senate President Godswill Akpabio, citing allegations of bias from the defense. The development came during Tuesday’s court proceedings, marking another twist in the high-profile legal battle that has gripped Nigeria’s political landscape.
“After careful consideration of the circumstances, I have decided to recuse myself from this matter,” Justice Egwuatu announced, directing that the case file be returned to the Chief Judge of the Federal High Court, Justice John Tsoho, for reassignment to another judge. The decision follows Akpabio’s formal expression of lack of confidence in the court’s impartiality regarding the case.
The dispute originated from a seating arrangement controversy in the Senate chamber that escalated into allegations of sexual harassment and abuse of office against Akpabio by Senator Natasha. The Senate subsequently suspended the female lawmaker for six months for misconduct, prompting her legal challenge. Justice Egwuatu had previously granted an ex-parte order restraining the Senate’s ethics committee from disciplinary proceedings against the senator.
Legal experts suggest the judge’s recusal could lead to significant delays in resolving the matter. “Case reassignments often reset the judicial clock, especially in politically sensitive matters like this,” noted constitutional lawyer Prof. Nnamdi Aduba. “This development underscores the delicate nature of cases involving high-ranking government officials.”
The Senate President’s legal team welcomed the decision, while Senator Natasha’s camp expressed confidence that justice would ultimately prevail. “We respect the court’s decision and believe the truth will come out under whichever judge eventually handles the case,” said Barr. Kayode Ajulo, counsel to Senator Natasha.
Observers note this case represents a critical test for Nigeria’s judiciary in handling disputes between legislative leaders and members. The Chief Judge is expected to assign the case to a new judge within the coming weeks, with all parties awaiting directions on when proceedings may recommence.
